Before releasing dark mode for visitors, we tested it on real WordPress sites with 29 themes, 10 page builders and 26 plugins, at phone and desktop sizes, in light and in dark. After release, we tested 23 more themes and 20 more plugins. This page lists what we tested and what we found.
How we test
Each theme, page builder and plugin gets its own WordPress test site, with sample posts, pages, comments, forms, menus and images. For every site we look at the home page, a post with comments, a page, an archive, search results, a “not found” page, and a page full of common parts: forms, pop-ups, accordions, tabs, drop-down menus, tooltips, lightboxes, buttons and embedded videos.
Each page is checked at phone width and at desktop width, in light mode and in dark mode. We check that:
- the page is dark from the moment it appears, with no white flash, including after a reload;
- text is easy to read, to the WCAG AA readability standard, including on buttons, menus and boxes, on hover and on focus;
- the page doesn’t jump or change its layout when you switch modes, and fonts and spacing stay the same;
- light mode looks exactly like the site without Mawu;
- photos are dimmed, not inverted, and the logo stays visible;
- videos and other embeds are left alone;
- menus, the mobile menu, pop-ups, dialogs, tabs, drop-downs, carousels and lightboxes are readable in dark mode;
- the switch is easy to reach and tap, doesn’t cover fixed bars, and works with a mouse, a finger and the keyboard;
- the page stays fast, with no stalls while it loads or scrolls, and no errors.
For page builders we also open the builder’s editor and check that Mawu stays out of the way there.
What the results mean
- Works well: every check passed on the pages we tested.
- Works with small issues: it works, with a small issue noted next to it.
- Known issue, a fix is planned: a visible issue we know about. A fix is planned.
Themes
| Theme | Result |
|---|---|
| Twenty Twenty-Five | Works well |
| Twenty Twenty-Four | Works well |
| Twenty Twenty-Three | Works with small issues: photos in posts can look a little brighter than on other themes |
| Twenty Twenty-One | Works well |
| Twenty Twenty | Works well |
| Astra | Works well |
| Blocksy | Works well |
| Neve | Works well |
| Storefront | Works well |
| Hello Elementor | Works well |
| Sydney | Works well |
| Ollie | Works well |
| Frost (the block theme) | Works well |
| Extendable | Works well |
| Kadence | Works with small issues: a post photo can be cropped slightly differently in light and dark |
| GeneratePress | Works with small issues: one pop-up on small phones needs another look |
| Hestia | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on one block when the page first loads |
| OceanWP | Known issue, a fix is planned: after switching back to light, a menu or search box can stay dark until the page reloads |
| Colibri WP | Known issue, a fix is planned: on desktop, the floating switch covers the fixed footer bar (move the switch to another corner for now) |
| Zakra | Known issue, a fix is planned: a brief light flash at the top of pages on desktop |
| Spectra One | Known issue, a fix is planned: a brief light flash on the first load of most pages |
| Worship | Works well (last tested 23 October) |
| Blockskit Photography | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (last tested 23 October) |
| Cathedral | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (last tested 23 October) |
| Bosa Finance Consult | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (last tested 23 October) |
| Mavix Cafe | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (last tested 23 October) |
| Chartered Accountant | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on first load on some pages (last tested 23 October) |
| Chocolate House | Known issue, a fix is planned: text over slider images can be hard to read in dark mode (last tested 23 October) |
| Blockbooster | Known issue: footer text was hard to read; a fix is made and waiting for a retest (last tested 23 October) |
| Twenty Twenty-Two | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Twenty Sixteen | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Bluehost Blueprint | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Twenty Fifteen | Works with small issues: small differences at tablet width (tested 29 October) |
| Twenty Nineteen | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on one block when the page first loads (tested 29 October) |
| Hello Biz | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on one block when the page first loads (tested 29 October) |
| Kubio | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (tested 29 October) |
| Go | Works with small issues: small differences on a few pages (tested 29 October) |
| Twenty Seventeen | Works with small issues: the site description over the header image has low contrast (tested 29 October) |
| Ploto | Works with small issues: scrolling can stutter a little on slower phones (tested 29 October) |
| Accountra | Known issue, a fix is planned: on phones, dark mode adds a little sideways scrolling (tested 29 October) |
| Fairport | Known issue, a fix is planned: cover blocks with a dark overlay can come out too light (tested 29 October) |
| VisualBlogger | Known issue, a fix is planned: cover blocks with a dark overlay can come out too light (tested 29 October) |
| Axis FSE | Known issue, a fix is planned: cover blocks with a dark overlay can come out too light, with hard-to-read text (tested 29 October) |
| Feminine Blog FSE | Known issue, a fix is planned: the hero area can look washed out, and one drop-down has low contrast (tested 29 October) |
| Color Magazine X | Known issue, a fix is planned: the “Back to top” link is hard to read (tested 29 October) |
| ColorMag | Known issue, a fix is planned: a brief light flash on the menu bar, a hard-to-see mobile menu icon, and the menu can stay dark after switching back to light (tested 29 October) |
| Horizon News | Known issue, a fix is planned: the loading screen flashes light on the first load (tested 29 October) |
| Inspiro | Known issue, a fix is planned: the mobile menu icon is hard to see, and the content moves down slightly in dark mode (tested 29 October) |
| Lightning | Known issue, a fix is planned: some panels can stay dark after switching back to light, and slider text can be hard to read (tested 29 October) |
| OnePress | Known issue, a fix is planned: the mobile menu button is hard to see on phones and tablets (tested 29 October) |
| PopularFX | Known issue, a fix is planned: the header flashes light on the first load, the mobile menu can stay dark after switching back to light, and some links have low contrast (tested 29 October) |
| Royal Elementor Kit | Known issue, a fix is planned: menu links and the pop-up close button have low contrast (tested 29 October) |
Page builders
| Page builder | Result |
|---|---|
| Elementor | Works well |
| Beaver Builder Lite | Works well |
| SiteOrigin Page Builder (with Widgets Bundle) | Works well |
| Brizy | Works well (editor checked; our test pages had no Brizy content) |
| Visual Composer | Works well (editor checked; our test pages had no Visual Composer content) |
| Spectra | Works well |
| Kadence Blocks | Works well |
| GenerateBlocks | Works well |
| Stackable | Works well |
| Otter Blocks | Works well |
Mawu Pro can show builder editors in dark: turn on Page builders: dark (Elementor then uses its own dark look, and previews are dark). We tested it with Elementor, Beaver Builder, SiteOrigin and Brizy. It is off by default.
Plugins
| Plugin | Result |
|---|---|
| Contact Form 7 | Works well |
| Fluent Forms | Works well |
| Ninja Forms | Works well |
| WPForms Lite | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on the form when the page first loads |
| Formidable Forms | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on the form when the page first loads |
| WooCommerce | Works with small issues: product and cart pages move slightly when switching (also seen on a block theme on 29 October), and the product gallery photo isn’t dimmed on phones on Storefront |
| Yoast SEO | Works well |
| Rank Math | Works well |
| Jetpack | Works well |
| CookieYes | Works well |
| Complianz | Works with small issues: the cookie pop-up covers the switch while it is open |
| Popup Maker | Works with small issues: an open pop-up covers the switch |
| MetaSlider | Works well |
| Smart Slider 3 | Works well |
| Modula | Works well |
| FooGallery | Works with small issues: placeholder tiles flash light on phones while photos load |
| Responsive Lightbox | Works well |
| Simple Lightbox | Works well |
| Polylang | Works well |
| The Events Calendar | Works well |
| bbPress | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on the forum header on first load |
| BuddyPress | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on some group and activity boxes on first load |
| Tutor LMS | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on course cards on first load |
| WP Super Cache | Works well |
| Autoptimize | Works well |
| LiteSpeed Cache | Works with small issues: the site title is a few pixels wider in dark mode on desktop |
| TablePress | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Leaflet Map | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Mailchimp for WP | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Cookie Notice | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| GDPR Cookie Compliance | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Ultimate Member | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Events Manager | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| FiboSearch | Works well (tested 29 October) |
| Shortcodes Ultimate | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on one box at desktop width (tested 29 October) |
| Table of Contents Plus | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on its box on Twenty Twenty-One (tested 29 October) |
| YITH WooCommerce Wishlist | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on first load on Storefront (tested 29 October) |
| Site Reviews | Works with small issues: a brief light flash on the review form on first load (tested 29 October) |
| Paid Memberships Pro | Known issue, a fix is planned: a brief light flash on the levels, checkout and login pages (tested 29 October) |
| LearnPress | Known issue, a fix is planned: on Twenty Twenty-One, course pages stay light; on block themes, course pages can flash light on first load, and the switch on the courses page responds to a click but not the Enter key (tested 29 October) |
| AddToAny Share Buttons | Known issue, a fix is planned: the share pop-up can stay dark after switching back to light (tested 29 October) |
We also checked Easy Table of Contents in part: its styles work in dark mode, but its box did not show on our test site, so we could not test it fully.
Readable text on coloured buttons and boxes
The last test round, on 28 October, found buttons, drop-down menus and gradient headings where text was hard to read on a bright or coloured background, mostly on hover. We fixed this before release. Mawu now checks text on bright and coloured buttons, menus and boxes, including on hover and focus, and keeps it readable. The themes and builders where we saw it, including Zakra, Hello Elementor, Sydney, Kadence and Stackable, passed the readability checks after the fix.
Known issues
A fix is planned for the issues above: the brief light flashes on a few themes and plugins, cover blocks that come out too light, menus and panels that stay dark after switching back to light, hard-to-see mobile menu buttons, low-contrast links, LearnPress on Twenty Twenty-One, the Colibri WP footer bar, and the small layout shifts. Until then, Never darken these parts and Never darken this page keep any problem part, or page, light.
Your theme isn’t listed?
Mawu works with most themes, but we can’t test them all. If a part of your site looks wrong in dark mode:
- Add it to Never darken these parts in Mawu → More settings → Frontend, or tick Never darken this page on that page.
- Tell us in the support forum, with your theme’s name and the page address. We add the themes people report to the next test round.
See dark mode for your website’s visitors for every setting.